Oct 14, 2024
REPORT: Hostages ABANDONED By Israel In Favor Of Gaza Land Grab
Israeli officials have table hostage talks in favor of annexing parts of the Gaza Strip.
- 15 minutes
What Israelis are trying to do
in the northern part of the Gaza Strip
is to empty it, basically
to send the citizens who are there.
We are talking about 350,000
to 400,000 to the south.
[00:00:18]
It goes hand in hand
with the plan or the agenda
of those settlers who are in government.
There are ministers who are settlers
who want to resettle
the northern part of the Gaza Strip.
[00:00:36]
The IDF has ramped up its military
operations in northern Gaza, and according
to reporting directly from Israeli media,
there's an ominous reason for that.
Insider sources in the Israeli military
say that they've all but abandoned
[00:00:53]
hopes of a hostage deal with Hamas,
and have also set their eyes on
essentially grabbing land in Gaza instead.
Oh, and allegedly eradicating Hamas.
As Haaretz reports in closed room
discussions, senior defense officials say
[00:01:10]
the chances of reaching a hostage deal
appear slim right now.
One of the reasons cited is that
since negotiations were suspended, there
has been no discussion among international
players involved in the talks.
I mean, as we've known, one of the
main reasons is the Netanyahu government
[00:01:28]
has absolutely no interest in engaging
in cease fire negotiations in good faith
or reaching a cease fire deal.
In addition, Israel's political leaders
haven't held any discussions
with the security branches
about the condition of the hostages.
[00:01:44]
So they have all been they've been
abandoned by the Israeli government.
Let's be clear about that.
Instead of focusing on returning
the captives, they've been escalating
military operations in northern Gaza.
Last night, for instance, there was
an IDF strike on a school in Gaza
[00:02:00]
where Palestinians were sheltering.
That ended up killing 22 people,
including, of course, children.
And this morning, a strike hit outside
Al-Aqsa hospital, killing five people
and injuring about 70 others,
some very severely.
[00:02:16]
Tents caught on fire
and residents were carried to.
Residents were carrying
injured individuals to the hospital,
and there was also a horrific video
showing one man who was burned alive,
[00:02:31]
IV drip attached to him and everything.
Army commanders in the field, who spoke
with Haaretz say the recent decision
to launch operations in northern Gaza
was taken without any in-depth discussion.
They said it appeared
that the operations were aimed principally
[00:02:47]
at pressuring local residents,
who were again told to evacuate the area
for the coast as winter is approaching
and remember,
upward of 80% of all buildings in Gaza
have been leveled, completely destroyed.
Keep that in mind when you also
consider the fact that winter is coming,
[00:03:05]
but wait until you hear about
the surrender or starve plan.
We're going to get to that
in just a moment.
But first thoughts?
Yeah, that's that's what I wanted
to go to first actually,
because, you know, they've cut off aid
to northern Gaza since October 1st.
So the starvation plan has begun already.
[00:03:23]
Before we get to it, though,
let me just say, look, I know that for
the rest of the planet, it's already
super clear what Israel is doing.
The right to self-defense
as an excuse they use. 12 months ago now,
it's been a year of brutal slaughter after
slaughter and relocating the Palestinians
[00:03:39]
and the ethnic cleansing and
the nonstop bombing of their neighbors.
So. So the only people left that are
to address, to get this change
are the people that are in power.
Right?
So the people in power here in America
and people in Israel.
[00:03:55]
And so for those folks, they think
that Israel is still defending themselves.
But once they do this operation
and they take northern Gaza, or they take
southern Lebanon, or they take both.
Remember, it's not like Israel
is going to admit it.
[00:04:12]
They're going to have
a whole new set of talking points.
Oh, we had to take half of Gaza
for security reasons.
And boy,
and you're creating a border zone.
And this is the only way to keep us safe.
And.
But remember, every imperial power
has said when taking land
[00:04:27]
that they were doing it for self-defense.
So there's going to be
no excuse left once.
This is pure ethnic cleansing,
pure theft of land.
So if you say, hey, look, in the old days,
you conquer land, you keep it.
That's what you do.
And a lot of people on social media,
probably mostly Israeli bots and trolls,
[00:04:46]
but but some real people
who are Israeli supporters are saying,
yeah, of course, why not take their land?
Take. We're conquering army.
Take their land.
Or at least you're being honest about it.
Okay, but that's in the old days, and we
were trying to get past the old days.
Why were we trying to get past old days?
[00:05:02]
Because in the old days,
there would be things like the Holocaust
where you would say, hey, you know what?
I'm going to create World War Two here,
and I'm going to take the Sudetenland.
I'm going to take Poland,
I'm going to take all this land.
And if anybody is in my way,
I'm going to kill them.
And then I need a scapegoat
like the Palestinians.
I mean, in that case, it was the Jews.
[00:05:17]
And so I'm going to say
that they're the dangerous people
and they're going to destroy all of us
unless we kill them first and then so
and then you go to kill them all.
So it's not like we
haven't seen this movie.
And I don't mean to say that, like,
right now, 6 million Palestinians
[00:05:33]
haven't been killed, only 42,000.
But remember when they started
doing the carpet bombing of Gaza?
Even the released hostages,
Israeli hostages, say today we thought
we're going to get killed.
We didn't understand
why they were dropping bombs
[00:05:49]
on the buildings we were in.
And the reason is because they
didn't give a damn about the hostages.
And now they're saying basically,
yeah, the hostages are dead.
We don't care about them.
We want the goddamn land.
And so keep it real. It's about land.
And if you don't understand that,
you're either deeply biased
[00:06:06]
or you just haven't realized
the pattern that's happening here,
that is super obvious to the rest of us.
So let's talk a little bit
about the surrender or starve plan.
So it is possible that the military
operations that are currently taking place
in northern Gaza
are essentially laying the groundwork for
[00:06:24]
this so-called surrender or starve plan.
Now, this plan was devised by a retired
major general by the name of Giora Eiland,
and was recently presented
to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
[00:06:40]
It calls for all residents of northern
Gaza to be evacuated within a week
to so-called humanitarian zones
in southern Gaza,
Those who choose to remain
would be considered Hamas militants
even if they are not Hamas militants,
[00:06:55]
even if they are elderly people
who are immobile,
even if they are severely injured,
individuals who aren't able to evacuate,
even though they might be individuals
who have nowhere else
to go for shelter, for safety.
They would be essentially military targets
because they would
[00:07:11]
be considered Hamas militants.
Even if they're not now, they
would be cut off from humanitarian aid,
and they would face hunger.
And Israel would then maintain
control over the North for an indefinite
period of time, meaning forever.
Okay, that is the plan.
Now, Eiland says that the only way
to stop Hamas and bring an end to the war
[00:07:31]
is to prevent its access to aid.
This is a direct quote.
I am not I'm not making this up.
I'm going to read it verbatim.
Here's what Guiora had to say.
They will either have to surrender
or to starve.
It doesn't necessarily mean
that we're going to kill every person,
[00:07:50]
it will not be necessary.
People will not be able to live there.
The water will dry up.
Okay, so if you are offended by my
earlier German analogy, sad day for you.
This is exactly what the Germans did.
[00:08:05]
It wasn't what they did at the end,
but it was.
We're not even at the beginning anymore.
Now we're in the middle.
So. But they're not militants.
And in fact, remember,
we're getting this from Haaretz.
Who's getting it from sources
inside the Israeli Defense Department.
[00:08:21]
Israeli defense officials and intelligence
officials, Shin bet officials write their
own government saying, what are we doing?
Are we really going to kill
all these people?
Are we really going to take this land
and then try to hold it, and we're
really going to slaughter them all.
We're going to starve them.
Are you guys serious?
[00:08:37]
And so they're going to the Israeli press
going, oh, they're serious.
They're actually going to slaughter
them all or starve them to death
just to take the land.
With our blessing, by the way. Yeah.
And our money.
And our money.
So we're paying for that genocide.
[00:08:53]
And now anyone who says it isn't
a genocide is totally delusional.
Utterly delusional.
So there's, like,
there's nothing left, guys.
All there is is just nonsense
talking points, justifying over-the-top
old school colonialism,
vicious imperialism, trying to take land.
[00:09:11]
If you're outraged by Putin trying to take
land in Ukraine, wait till you get a load
of Netanyahu all over the Middle East.
I want to go to our own.
Bregman, who is a teaching fellow
at King's College London
and a former Israeli military officer.
Here he is describing
what he believes will happen in Gaza.
[00:09:31]
I know exactly what's going to happen
in terms of the dynamic.
They will empty the northern part
of the Gaza Strip.
They will establish military camps there,
connected to electricity and water,
and then settlers will move in.
[00:09:50]
That's the long term plan.
So Yoav Galant, who is
the Israeli minister of defense, told US
Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin that
the IDF is not carrying out this plan.
It's just that everything that you see
transpiring in northern Gaza at the moment
[00:10:08]
is a coincidence, in that it's exactly
what the plan describes.
- But they're not carrying out the plan.
- Yeah.
That's why Israeli defense officials and
Shin Bet officials are going in a panic to
the Israeli press, saying it is the plan.
It is the plan. Right.
[00:10:23]
And that is the idea that Israeli defense
officials and Shin Bet officials
would be saying, watch out for Israel,
and the current government is going
to ethnically cleanse these people.
That means Israel has
jumped the shark months ago.
[00:10:38]
They're desperate at this point
to get you the news.
We're about to do something horrific.
And so it's not about you.
By the way, they started on October 1st,
so how could it be a coincidence
when you say, oh,
the surrender or starve plan is
a coincidence,
[00:10:53]
but I stopped allowing food into and water
into northern Gaza two weeks ago.
That's not a coincidence.
That's just the direct action
that you took.
So in the context of all this, guys,
now, when you look at the fact that
the IDF and the Israeli government, again,
[00:11:12]
according to the Israeli press and no one
disputes this anymore, knew about October
7th and chose not to do anything about it.
Their official explanation is
we didn't think they could really do it.
But currently we see that Israel has
incredible intelligence operation, right?
[00:11:28]
So they just missed the biggest attack
on Israel ever, even though they knew
about it, but chose not to do anything.
And then you see, all of
a sudden the excuse is Naomi Klein again
brilliantly explains in her piece about,
oh, we are the victims we
[00:11:44]
we were forced to defend ourselves.
And since we're defending ourselves,
we're allowed to take
as much land as we like and kill
as many Palestinians and Arabs as we like,
and coincidentally invade
other countries that are nearby
and maybe take their land as well.
Right.
[00:11:59]
And remember, it took the IDF a long time
to even respond to what happened on
October 7th, because all of the soldiers
were stationed near the West Bank.
I mean, really, you're not going to have
any military stationed near Gaza.
[00:12:15]
You know, even if you think
that Hamas didn't have the capability
to carry out the kind of attack
they did on October 7th,
wouldn't you, as Prime Minister,
want to ensure that you have
a security presence near Gaza,
just in case Hamas has that capability.
Let alone the fact that it took them hours
and hours and hours to get there
[00:12:33]
while people were being killed
and sexually assaulted and taken hostage.
And the IDF was nowhere to be found.
Right.
For an enormous period of time, but I'm
sure that also was a giant coincidence.
But it doesn't matter
whether you think October 7th,
[00:12:50]
they let it happen on purpose.
Not all of Israel, obviously.
The people in Israel that got killed
didn't want to be killed.
The people taken hostage
didn't want to be taken hostage.
We're talking about
government officials, guys.
It's never about ethnic identity.
North Korea and South Korea
are the same exact identity.
They have two very different governments
that lead to two very different results.
[00:13:09]
And North Korea, they have concentration
camps just like Israel does in Gaza.
Okay. It isn't because of their ethnicity.
It's because power corrupts
and absolute power corrupts absolutely.
And as they're doing this insane lunatic
plan with a deeply right wing government
[00:13:26]
of Israel, America is going, attaboy!
Here's more money
and more money and more money.
And if you kill more
and you take more land,
we're going to send you even more money.
And right now, by the way,
we're amping up Israel's defense forces.
But we say because some Hezbollah
rockets got through
[00:13:44]
and they're like, wow, it happened.
Like, I can't believe it.
It turns out we might lose 1 or 2 people.
In fact, in this case,
they lost four soldiers.
Wait, I thought Hezbollah
was vicious terrorists
who only wanted to kill civilians.
Why did they targeted a military base?
Wounded 61, killed four.
[00:14:00]
Okay, so, by the way,
their, kill ratio of civilians to,
to fighters for Israel is way, way,
way worse than Hamas or Hezbollah
while they pretend to be innocent.
So, guys, at the at the end of the day,
[00:14:17]
right now, Israel is executing this plan
exactly as the people inside
the Israeli government have warned us.
They are not a monolith,
but they but we do have a fringe lunatic,
part of the Israeli government
that has taken over completely.
[00:14:33]
And if we keep sending them money,
they're going to keep doing this plan,
and then we're all going to be
morally responsible for one
of the worst genocides of our lifetime.
Well, we will continue sending them money.
Both political parties support
what is currently happening in Gaza,
[00:14:49]
in the West Bank, in Lebanon, in Syria,
potentially a full blown war with Iran.
There is no difference between
the two political parties on this issue.
So I am disgusted by the fact that we
are morally culpable for what's happening.
[00:15:06]
But the American people apparently
have absolutely no choice.
You have a uniparty
on this issue and that's it.
Thanks for watching The Young Turks
really appreciate it.
Another way to show support
is through YouTube memberships.
You'll get to interact with us more.
There's live chat emojis, badges.
[00:15:23]
You've got emojis of me
Anna John Jr. So those are super fun.
But you also get playback
of our exclusive member only shows
and specials right after they air.
So all of that, all you got
to do is click that join button
right underneath the video.
[00:15:38]
Thank you.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks: October 14, 2024
Hosts: Cenk UygurAna Kasparian
- 15 minutes
- 14 minutes
- 10 minutes
- 13 minutes
- 11 minutes
- 9 minutes
- 15 minutes
- 8 minutes