Oct 17, 2024
Trump HORRIFIES Undecided Voter In Town Hall
Former President Donald Trump falsely assured an undecided voter that Haitian immigrants are eating cats, dogs, and “other things during a town hall.
- 12 minutes
Do you really believe that these people
are eating the people's pets and eating.
- Other things too?
- This is where we are.
This is our election. Welcome to America.
An undecided Latino voter who's actually
a longtime registered Republican,
[00:00:19]
asked Donald Trump about some
of his rhetoric in regard to immigration
and specifically the Haitian community
in Springfield, Ohio.
This was during a Univision town hall.
Now, Trump's response didn't inspire
any confidence that his divisive rhetoric
[00:00:37]
is going to change anytime soon.
We're going to get to his answer
in a second.
But first, let me read the question
that was asked by the undecided voter.
He asks.
The authorities in Springfield, Ohio, more
than one time clarified that the Haitians
are not eating their cats and their dogs.
[00:00:53]
Nonetheless, you want to revoke
the permanent, basically the Visa, they
have to legally reside in the country.
Do you really believe that these people
are eating the people's pets?
Now here is how Donald Trump responded.
[00:01:12]
This was just reported.
I was I was just saying
what was reported that's been reported
and eating other things too,
that they're not supposed to be.
But this is all I do is report I have
not I was there, I'm going to be there
and we're going to take a look
and I'll give you a full report when I do.
[00:01:30]
But that's been in the newspapers
and reported pretty broadly.
He's just a reporter, guys.
He's just a reporter.
I mean, he heard reports
and then he repeats the reports.
He doesn't look into it.
He doesn't question anything that,
you know, might sound a little outlandish,
[00:01:48]
because if he has an opportunity to
demagogue and engage in incredibly gross,
inaccurate, false, hateful rhetoric
that's going to direct hatred
toward innocent people who, by the way,
are not in the country illegally.
[00:02:03]
These are Haitian migrants
who have temporary protected status.
Okay.
The United States government
implemented the protected status
for Haitians after there was
a devastating earthquake in Haiti.
And after, you know,
some of our foreign policy
[00:02:18]
kind of destroyed their country as well.
And the idea that they're
being demonized like this.
And he just won't stop. He won't stop.
Later in his answer,
he brings up like relevant points.
And if he had started with that,
I would be fine with it.
[00:02:34]
Right?
If he didn't go as low
as making up these dumb stories,
hateful stories that direct hatred toward
innocent people, I'd be fine with it.
But he can't do it.
He has to go this low and he has
to continue like he never apologizes.
[00:02:49]
He never recalibrates.
He continues on with the garbage
and I can't stand it.
Yeah.
So, there's two things in that answer.
And in even in the question that are so
important to the substance of this issue.
And I want to come back
to that in a in a second.
[00:03:04]
But guys, what are we doing here?
I mean, I watched Kamala Harris interview
on Fox News and she was relatively smooth.
She didn't answer
a couple of the questions.
That really annoyed me that she
didn't answer some of those questions.
But then you turn to Trump and he's
like an escaped mental patient, right?
[00:03:22]
And he's like,
they're eating the the cats, the dogs.
They say the dogs are hot,
but I don't know.
They now they're eating other things
like the tuna and the salmon.
And I hear the Japanese are joining them.
They're eating the tuna
and the salmon too.
They're calling it sushi. Okay.
And then they're taking the chicken
and they're eating their eggs raw.
[00:03:38]
They're eating it raw.
It's it's disgusting. It's crazy.
- We've got to kick him out of here, okay?
- They don't even cook it.
And they take the pigs and the cows,
and they even eat them.
And they put them together,
and they call it a hamburger.
It's crazy.
- It is.
- Crazy.
Sometimes they bury the pig
to roast it in the dirt.
Those are Hawaiians.
Were kicking them out.
[00:03:55]
Sir. They're Americans, I don't care.
I don't care because I just escaped.
And this feels like freedom to me.
Thank God I got that white coat off of me.
Okay, so look, who should you vote for?
The mental patient.
I don't know.
I say put him back in. But anyways.
[00:04:11]
Oh. They're trying to impress him.
No, no, no, it's an analogy.
All right.
Anyways, And he's just reporting it, guys.
He's just reporting it.
Every reporter has said it's not true.
Every Republican in the area,
the mayor, etc.
Have said it's not true.
So why are you still reporting things
that are untrue?
[00:04:29]
That's because you're lying.
We have a word for it.
- Lying?
- Exactly.
I'm saying it like Trump
so you can understand it.
- Okay.
- So. Oh go ahead.
Jake, did you have something else?
- I wanted to get.
- To the substance of.
It. Yeah.
So the second half of his response
to this again, Republican voter
[00:04:45]
who's probably undecided in this election
because he doesn't like
the divisive crap that Trump is saying.
Right.
But in the second half of his answer,
he brings up some
of the legitimate concerns, right?
It's not demonizing the migrants.
But there is a problem when you have
a massive influx of people coming into a
[00:05:04]
small town without the federal government
providing the support that the town needs,
that is a legitimate concern.
So let's hear what Trump had to say.
As far as Springfield is concerned,
because I do know that situation.
You have a city of 52,000 people,
and they've added almost 30,000,
[00:05:23]
migrants into the city.
If you were a person that lived there,
if you lived in Springfield, Ohio,
and all of a sudden
you couldn't get into a hospital,
you couldn't get your children
into a school,
you wouldn't be able to buy groceries.
You could no longer pay the rent
because the government is paying rent.
[00:05:39]
Any of that, if any of that happened,
it would be a disaster for you
and you wouldn't be happy.
We want to make our people safe and
secure, and we want to make them happy.
But Springfield, Ohio
is a perfect example.
You have a town.
A beautiful little town with no problems.
[00:05:57]
All of a sudden they have 30
or 32,000 people dropped into the town.
Okay, so is it a little under 30,000?
Is it 30 to 32,000?
Like, notice that the numbers change.
And let's actually put it side by side.
[00:06:13]
Let's take a look at the next video.
You have a city of 52,000 people
and they've added almost 30,000,
migrants into the city.
You have a town,
a beautiful little town with no problems.
All of a sudden they have 30
or 32,000 people dropped into the town.
[00:06:33]
Okay, interesting.
Well, prior to this, the number was lower
when he was speaking about it.
Let's take a look at that.
In Springfield, Ohio,
20,000 illegal Haitian migrants have
descended upon a town of 58,000 people,
destroying their way of life.
[00:06:49]
They've destroyed the place.
So notice how in the town hall,
he exaggerates the number
of Haitian migrants in Springfield, Ohio.
Because it doesn't matter.
The facts don't really matter.
This is an issue that he doesn't really
seem all that interested in learning about
[00:07:09]
and finding solutions for.
It is a campaign issue for him.
It worked for him in 2016.
He's hoping it's going
to work for him now.
And in the meantime, you have both
migrants who are struggling and you
have communities that are struggling.
I actually do care about the people
in Springfield, Ohio.
[00:07:26]
I do think that it is difficult
for a small town
to take in a massive influx of migrants
without help from the federal government,
but we never find solutions
to immigration,
because if we're all being honest,
not a single politician actually cares
[00:07:41]
about solving the issue once and for all.
Not a single politician
wants to reform immigration.
A lot of these Republicans
who purport to care so much about
this issue are taking bribes,
legal bribes from their campaign donors
who do not want anything
[00:07:57]
to be done about immigration
because they love exploiting that cheap
labor that they can pay even lower
than minimum wage
because they don't have the ability to go
complain about it to the authorities.
That's what the reality
of this situation really is.
And it disgusts me
that whenever the campaign starts,
[00:08:14]
this type of gross rhetoric
demonizing innocent people pops up.
I don't like it.
It's divisive, and it is not helpful
at all in terms of finding solutions
for any problems we might have.
Okay, so he said illegal Haitian
immigrants, but as the questioner pointed
[00:08:31]
out, they actually do have legal status.
So that's a fact. That's not arguable.
So Trump's proposal.
So actually, before I explain Trump's
proposal and his proposal you just heard,
which is, hey,
if the federal government
is going to put 20,000 immigrants
[00:08:47]
in a town of 58,000, let's take
Trump's original numbers, right?
That's still a big number.
And the federal government
should help that town adjust.
Otherwise, yeah, you're going
to have some issues, right?
Of course.
And so that's
a reasonable position to take.
That's a position I hope all of us take
so that it's not all
[00:09:04]
on the residents of Springfield.
Right now, Trump's position
is not that Trump's position
is take away their legal status.
And that was the exact question
that that gentleman asked.
He said, you say this conspiracy story
about the pets and the being eaten,
[00:09:22]
and then you said, so I'm going
to take away their legal status.
Are you really going to take away
their legal status?
And that's actually a really
important question for a lot of people
that live in this country,
because a lot of people have,
green cards and temporary legal residence,
and they haven't done anything wrong.
They're not illegal at all. Right.
[00:09:39]
But and and people have family members
that are in that category.
And Trump is now saying,
if I make up a story that isn't
even true at all and use that story,
I could take away your legal rights.
Well that's concerning.
I mean, that guy's a lifelong Republican
that asked the question,
[00:09:56]
but he's concerned about that, right?
And that is a very legitimate concern.
And Trump is saying, yeah,
that's what I'm going to do.
I'm going to.
You got legal rights. I don't care at all.
If you're an immigrant,
I'm going to say you're illegal.
I'm going to strip you of your rights.
And by the way,
when he was in office the first time.
Yeah, he got checked by the establishment
and they put some brakes on his car,
[00:10:15]
but he had suggested.
And Stephen Miller had suggested.
Well, even if you're already a US citizen,
if you came from another country,
are you really a citizen?
So they're even thinking of taking
birthright citizenship away.
So this is not hyperbole.
Stephen Miller suggested it.
[00:10:33]
You could look it up.
So what he's proposing is terrible.
And if you actually care about
immigration, which Anna does, I do.
And so many people
on the right and the left do.
Well, then why did this is the one thing
Kamala Harris is definitely right about?
Why did he prevent the bill that everyone
agrees to, that an Oklahoma Republican
[00:10:51]
wrote that actually is largely it
should be embarrassing to the Democrats.
It's not only completely Republican bill,
it's largely Trump's ideas.
And he said, vote no.
I don't want the problem fixed
because I want to use it in my campaign.
He's a terrible guy
who only thinks about himself.
[00:11:08]
He doesn't care about the laws.
He doesn't care about breaking the laws.
He just cares about power.
And finally, the guy was using
an interpreter, just to be clear, right?
He speaks Spanish
better than he speaks English.
The guy asking the question.
And Trump in the middle of his crazed
answer about how he's going to take away
[00:11:24]
their legal status, et Cetera said.
You know, it's terrible.
A lot of people, they don't even speak
the language and you can't talk to them.
And then they have to bring in
all these interpreters.
It's terrible.
The guy was using an
interpreter for the question.
Yeah, I'm sure he definitely
persuaded the individual
[00:11:43]
to vote for Trump in the election.
I mean, it's just look, it's amazing
because I actually think it would be
even more difficult to beat Donald Trump
if he had a little bit of self-control.
But he doesn't have self-control.
Oh my God.
If he had self-control, he'd be up by ten.
Easy.
[00:11:59]
I mean, first of all,
if he had self-control,
he wouldn't have done January 6th and
tried to murder his own vice president and
try to terminate the Constitution and send
in an angry mob to attack our Capitol.
And we're still having a Congress,
and the Democrats are still losing to him
by a little bit right now.
And best case scenario, they're tied
right now to that guy, and they don't.
[00:12:17]
Then the Democrats don't realize
that they have a problem.
They think everything is hunky dory.
No, they do think they have a problem.
They think their problem is Jill Stein.
Oh Jesus Christ guys man.
Democrats do better.
You should be blowing this guy out.
He's an escaped mental patient.
And if you're tied with him,
you got to fix your own problems.
[00:12:36]
Good luck to us in doing that
because the establishment
never, ever wants to do that.
And Republicans,
if you want to win an election,
try someone non-insane for a change.
I know a radical thought, but you'd
win fairly easily in this context
with a super weak Democratic party.
[00:12:53]
Thanks for watching.
If you become a member,
you get to watch all this ad free.
Except for of course,
this ad still hit the join button below.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks: October 17, 2024
Hosts: Cenk UygurAna Kasparian
- 19 minutes
- 17 minutes
- 12 minutes
- 7 minutes
- 11 minutes
- 23 minutes